Never Miss an Update From The Endless Customers Podcast
Get the latest episodes delivered directly to your inbox with the latest insights, tactics, and success stories.
The 5 Marketing Metrics That Matter More Than Website Traffic [Endless Customers Podcast Ep. 183]
Share
Listen on
At a Glance
What marketing metrics matter more than website traffic?
These five metrics show whether your marketing is winning customers better than traffic can. IMPACT coach Brian Casey splits each one into paid and earned channels.
-
Cost per lead
-
Close rate
-
Sales cycle time
-
Lead volume and quality
-
Website engagement (bounce rate, pages per session, conversions)
Who this episode is for
- Business owners deciding whether to keep funding content after organic traffic dropped
- Marketing leaders who need a scorecard their CEO will trust more than a sessions chart
- Sales leaders who want marketing judged by how ready to buy their opportunities are
- Teams that want to measure AI visibility without paying for another tool
View the full transcription of this episode.
This transcript has been generated by AI and not checked for accuracy.
[00:00:00] Bob Ruffolo: If organic traffic to your website is falling, does that mean that your marketing is failing? No, not necessarily. But what it does mean is that the old inbound scorecard can no longer tell whether your business is actually winning, because traffic was never the goal, customers were. In this episode, Endless Customers coach Brian Casey and I break down the marketing metrics that matter in the age of AI, including cost per lead, close rate, sales cycle times, lead quality, and website engagement.
[00:00:27] Bob Ruffolo: You'll learn why perfect attribution is impossible, how to separate paid performance from customers you've earned, and what AI citations and buy activity can reveal about your visibility. Now stick around till the end because Brian explains why the companies AI recommends won't be the ones that are making the boldest claims.
[00:00:43] Bob Ruffolo: They'll be the ones that can prove those claims and earn buyers' trust. Let's get into it.​
[00:01:31] Bob Ruffolo: And welcome back to the Endless Customers Podcast. We have a great episode today. We've got one of my favorite Endless Customers coaches on the planet. Um, many of you have probably worked with him before. Brian Casey, welcome back to the show
[00:01:45] Brian Casey: Thanks. Good to be back
[00:01:47] Bob Ruffolo: Now, Brian, we've been, uh, having some interesting conversations because, uh, AI has broken the entire inbound marketing funnel. Uh, when we first started working together, the whole thing was [00:02:00] traffic leads and sales. Um, our metrics were all around generating traffic, organic traffic, all sorts of, you know, traffic from gen-- uh, all sorts of traffic from different sources, um, and then obviously converted to leads.
[00:02:13] Bob Ruffolo: But, you know, clients are probably asking now in this age of AI when we're seeing a often a, a drop in organic traffic to business websites, um, what metrics should we be tracking? So I thought that was an interesting conversation. You've been working directly with our clients. You're helping navigate all this.
[00:02:28] Bob Ruffolo: Um, so we'll just start right here. Um, obviously, we're seeing a drop in organic traffic across the board. I think everyone knows that. That's not a secret anymore. Um, but what metrics are you actually tracking with clients? We'll just jump right into it
[00:02:43] Brian Casey: Yeah. Well, one, one piece of the puzzle, that I wanna highlight around organic traffic is there seems to be a regression to the mean. if you've historically had a lot of organic traffic, you're probably gonna fall. [00:03:00] If you've historically not had a lot of organic traffic, there is still room to be gained. So a lot of clients that, uh, have not historically created content are still seeing increases in organic traffic. Uh, I don't know what the future of that looks like, but I'm kind of been thinking about organic traffic as more like regression to the mean versus universal law everybody's just going to decrease.
[00:03:24] Bob Ruffolo: I like that, it makes a lot of sense. So, um, regression to the mean so if you've been following the inbound marketing playbook for many years and you've been publishing three pieces of content a week like we've always advised, um, used generally a lot of traffic from Google through those articles but that-- Google is just not sending that traffic to those articles anymore so you're seeing a drop.
[00:03:46] Bob Ruffolo: But if you have never published articles before and you're just saying hey, we need to start doing this and you start writing articles, Google is still sending some traffic and you're still gonna capture some of that Um, and then yeah s-that's okay, that makes sense. [00:04:00] Um, cool well keep going .So, so okays organic traffic for some companies were are gonna be focusing on If its dropping for others Like We will pay attention ,but It’s Not The End Of The World Where Do You Go From There
[00:04:11] Brian Casey: The mindset, to me has completely shifted. Um, organic as a term has historically been attached to search in Google.
[00:04:21] Bob Ruffolo: Mm-hmm.
[00:04:22] Brian Casey: Um, really just broadly means non-paid.
[00:04:27] Bob Ruffolo: That's right
[00:04:27] Brian Casey: So the biggest mindset shift that I'm kind of out there is what does it take for us to bring in non-paid leads and sales? so I'm looking at big picture metrics like cost per lead.
[00:04:44] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:04:44] Brian Casey: like what is our close rate with people that we're paying through uh, ads or paid social versus what is our close rate from our non-paid channels? Um, eh, the traffic piece is [00:05:00] still important but only because of how it impacts your conversion rate. Yeah.
[00:05:04] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah.
[00:05:05] Brian Casey: So
[00:05:06] Bob Ruffolo: so
[00:05:06] Brian Casey: conversion rate and how people are leveraging your website is more important because there may be less people on it, and so you need to capitalize more on what they're doing when they're there.
[00:05:17] Bob Ruffolo: so I know that a lot of this audience, you know, they like to have scorecards, right? They wanna know what's the handful of metrics we should be tracking so we know that these metrics, if they're all starting to go up in the right direction, it's ultimately gonna lead to better outcomes, which is more customers.
[00:05:31] Bob Ruffolo: So as you're looking at the clients that you're working with and you're saying, "Okay, well maybe traffic for many of them is going to be going down. Let's not freak out." We've gotta pay attention to these other metrics, and this is probably broadly what most of the audience should have on their scorecards.
[00:05:46] Bob Ruffolo: What are you seeing as other metrics we should be tracking?
[00:05:48] Brian Casey: uh, the-- I, I think the biggest one, I have a list of metrics that I think historically we've not focused on as much. I'll run down that and then I have a few more. So cost per lead is kind [00:06:00] of the biggest one that I'm getting people to track.
[00:06:02] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. Yeah
[00:06:02] Brian Casey: Uh, and then breaking things down from your non-paid to your paid channels.
[00:06:06] Brian Casey: So looking at things like close rate or cycle time, how many leads are you generating from non-paid or earned versus your paid channel? Um, sales from non-paid versus paid. And then I think there's a host of website metrics, things like page views per session, bounce rate, uh, conversion rate on the website.
[00:06:28] Brian Casey: Those have all been like the page per session, the bounce rate have historically been like, "Yeah, we should do something about that," in the back burner. Now it's like have fewer potential eyeballs on our site. We need to capitalize more on them. Um, so I think those are a handful of them. And then I think you have some that are things that you would have to figure out, how to track that might be more difficult on a scorecard.
[00:06:53] Brian Casey: So things like, um, attribution.
[00:06:57] Bob Ruffolo: Hmm
[00:06:58] Brian Casey: How many people are coming to us [00:07:00] as a result of the content and the voice that we've created? And it's a little bit more difficult 'cause you can't just, use Google Analytics for that necessarily.
[00:07:09] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:07:10] Brian Casey: things like sales team feedback. Um, I had a client of mine that sold, uh, you know, a higher than average, um, ADU, and he was like, "It was crazy."
[00:07:23] Brian Casey: I thought that they were, um, a competitor because of how seamless it was, and it was just a frictionless process, and it was a massive, like, ticket, and it went very smoothly and quickly. he said something to the effect of like, "Well, whatever you're doing is working." Um, and so it's like that friction list, you'll see it downstream with
[00:07:44] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:07:45] Brian Casey: and cycle time. Um, so I think there's a handful of website metrics, there's a handful of sales metrics, and there's still some marketing metrics that you need to be tracking
[00:07:54] Bob Ruffolo: You know, it's interesting, um, as you're saying this, there's, um... I like that we're going into quantitative metrics [00:08:00] versus qualitative metrics. Um, and I don't think, you know, a lot of people when they think about metrics, they just think quantitative. Like my website traffic is going down, I'm blogging, maybe we shouldn't be blogging anymore 'cause my website traffic is down and maybe that's not working anymore, which is totally incorrect, and we'll go into, to why.
[00:08:18] Bob Ruffolo: We just had a whole episode with Stephanie where we talked about that. Um, but the qualitative metrics is a l- There's a lot more judgment in that. There's a lot more feelings, there's a lot more emotions, and there's also just a lot more, um, just like, like what you were just saying, you know? The sales team is happier.
[00:08:38] Bob Ruffolo: They are feeling more supported, that the leads that are coming in are, are more qualified and ready to buy. And sur- certainly you could probably put quantitative metrics like did this lead meet all this criteria so it's a quantitative qualified lead. But, you know, a happy sales team that feels like they can be more productive has a big impact on the culture and the future of the business as well, [00:09:00] and that's very qualitative.
[00:09:01] Bob Ruffolo: Um, and you know, so, so you have a lot of that going on. Um, you mentioned attribution, which attribution to me is also very qualitative, and I know there's quantitative ways of looking at it. Anyone that knows me, I know our coaches don't all agree on this, w- don't all, all agree with me, I am not a fan of attribution because I think it's impossible to track.
[00:09:22] Bob Ruffolo: First touch, last touch, weighted models. Um, you know, because attribution, you can have 100 touch points that all affected the sale because I believed in the brand, because I knew this person over here user or I saw this review or I did this. Because we're all doing a million things before we ever reach out to say, " Is this the, the company we should go?"
[00:09:43] Bob Ruffolo: Is it because ChatGPT recommended us? Is it because, you know, somewhere I, I've been following this brand even though, you know, from a distance? Um, and by the way, we forget more stuff than we actually remember. So if people say, "Hey, how did you hear about us?" We're like, "Um, I think it was this." What, are we gonna count on that as data?
[00:09:59] Bob Ruffolo: It's like [00:10:00] no, there's subconscious things of, of why we made a decision that we'll never actually let people know. So I am not a fan of attribution at all. How do you feel about attribution? I mean, you mentioned that as something you're looking at, but we might have a difference of opinion here
[00:10:13] Brian Casey: Yeah, I, I think there's benefit to be gained from understanding the known impact that things have
[00:10:23] Bob Ruffolo: Mm-hmm.
[00:10:23] Brian Casey: on close one deals.
[00:10:26] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:10:27] Brian Casey: And I think you're never gonna have the full picture, and I think it's impossible to have the full picture.
[00:10:32] Bob Ruffolo: I agree with you. I agree with you 100% on that. We are fully aligned
[00:10:36] Brian Casey: a lot of home service based businesses, their website conversion rate might still be lower than what a SaaS company might be, but they're getting a ton of calls.
[00:10:47] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:10:48] Brian Casey: when someone calls in and they say-- and th-the company is smart enough to say: "How'd you hear about us?" And they say Google, does that mean organic? Does that mean AI overview? Does that mean [00:11:00] they don't actually know what Google is and they were just looking online? Like, it can mean any number of Um,
[00:11:06] Bob Ruffolo: exactly right. You're exactly right. So I think there's... Yeah, you're right. It's, it's in- it's information but yeah, I think anyone that is saying, "Hey, we have to have perfect attribution reporting in our company," you're, you're focused on the wrong thing. Um, now I do think paid can give you much greater information especially if using mature paid ad platforms.
[00:11:30] Bob Ruffolo: Uh, may I say mature ad platforms? Obviously Google Mature gives you tons of metrics. Meta Mature gives you tons of metrics. If you're on advertising Amazon Mature gives you great metrics. Um, and then you can go down some other ones too; Snapchat, TikTok whatever you're advertising on. Um, but there's also immature ones like OpenAI uh, that doesn't give you a lot of information so um, it, it's hard to track you know as they say paid channel that we generate this sales opportunity became a [00:12:00] customer or is this an earned channel?
[00:12:03] Bob Ruffolo: And I would also argue that they b- they blur right? You may have somebody come in from a paid channel but then they really experience all the other things that you've been focusing on. They read the reviews and you have a review generation thing going on. They've read a, a ... You know gone through your content or even asked ChatGPT more about this company and all of the stuff you're doing organically is actually fueling re- recommendations saying, "Yeah this would be a good company for you to go with."
[00:12:26] Bob Ruffolo: So again I know we're going down some rabbit holes o- on attribution again here, but i- I think the moral of the story is it's hard to track these days. It's a lot harder to track these days
[00:12:37] Brian Casey: Yeah, I think it's impossible to have true attribution. I think anybody who's trying to figure that out or anybody who's trying to sell you true attribution selling you a false bag of goods. Um, and ultimately, that's kind of why like from a metric standpoint, I'm looking at things like cost per lead from channels that we actually know in [00:13:00] close rate and cycle time.
[00:13:01] Brian Casey: It's like how are the people that are coming to us, coming to us in the first place? And what is their experience like in working with us? And is it more frictionless than competitors? Like do we win deals more often everybody else? And I think it's difficult to know if you're an Endless Customer mature environment If it was an article that they saw initially or a Facebook post um, it's difficult to know how big of an influence a buyer's guide that you have assignment sold them might play versus how much depersonalized video that you sent them. and i-it's just-- it's difficult
[00:13:47] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah, no. You know, I th- I do think one of the things that from a metrics standpoint we should be tracking, uh, y- i- I know this is something that you guys work really closely with your, your clients, is just consistent output, [00:14:00] whatever that output is. Um, are we publishing consistently? Are we generating reviews consistently?
[00:14:05] Bob Ruffolo: Um, are we publishing customer proof and case studies consistently? Um, because that, those are probably the biggest signals today to both humans and AI of is this a company that's credible and worth doing business with? Now, we've all had experiences where we've gone to Amazon and we go to the reviews.
[00:14:26] Bob Ruffolo: We always look at the recent reviews. We look at the, um, uh, the bad reviews before we look at the good reviews and how bad are the bad ones or, and are there consistency between the bad ones. AI is just thinking the same way as humans do. Um, so how are we getting ahead of that as a business? I mean, that would be a metric I would absolutely be tracking is, is the, you know, our, our, our reputation management and having some metrics around that.
[00:14:48] Bob Ruffolo: Uh,
[00:14:49] Brian Casey: Yeah
[00:14:49] Bob Ruffolo: what else are you seeing from a metrics that might not be so much in terms of, uh, performance but in terms of output?
[00:14:58] Brian Casey: I think the, the [00:15:00] content production and also like how you're amplifying it, and uh, I think you could have evidence to prove that you're becoming more known. you can look at branded versus non-branded traffic.
[00:15:14] Bob Ruffolo: Hmm
[00:15:15] Brian Casey: the line that I've typically said is like you-- if you have a really good brand reputation, you're known for who you are, and historically inbound has helped you to be known for what you do and not who you are. And now you have to be known for both
[00:15:30] Bob Ruffolo: That's a, what a great insight right there. That makes so much sense
[00:15:35] Brian Casey: Yeah. So I think the, how many people know you and recognize you is one of those things, and you can actually track that. You can track branded traffic through Search Console, through Semrush, through like a ton of tools, both free and paid, to tell, like, how much do people know who we are. And then historically, uh, you know, question-driven content [00:16:00] has helped to answer and address the question of like, what do we do?
[00:16:05] Bob Ruffolo: You know, you have a flywheel effect going on here, right? So the more that you do quality work, the better reputation you'll have. If you're amplifying that by t- sharing those stories, these great success stories on your website, you're generating more reviews, you're amplifying your, your reputation, which is gonna give you more recommendations, but both from human and AI or search recommending you more.
[00:16:30] Bob Ruffolo: But even the human recommendations, if you're doing great work, probably the most important thing anyone could do here is ... The best marketing strategy is be a good business does good work. We've talked about that many times on this show. Start there . You know? Don't even worry about like the, the content, the tactics and all the stuff we talk about until you have a great business, um, because this all comes back to branded, uh, traffic or branded lead generation.
[00:16:55] Bob Ruffolo: Um, I think about in our local market here in Connecticut, not yours, but [00:17:00] mine, um, there's a company called Connecticut Basement Systems, and if you have a basement issue... And they did such a good job with their marketing of getting their name out there and everything, but they have such a great reputation.
[00:17:10] Bob Ruffolo: And when your basement, my basement flooded and I had to have mediation and, and ha- put a sump pump system in, they were more expensive but they had a lifetime warranty, and everyone that I talked to was like, "Are you gonna call Connecticut Basement Systems? Do you wanna call Connecticut Basement Systems?
[00:17:25] Bob Ruffolo: Do you wanna call Connecticut Basement Systems?" Obviously those conversations are not tracked, so we talk about metrics here. You can't track that. If someone was to say, "Hey why'd you reach out to Connecticut Basement Systems?" I'd be like, "I don't know, everyone told me about them," right? Well, well who? How you, how do you connect that back to attribution?
[00:17:40] Bob Ruffolo: It's like which job did we do that we did a good job on that actually got the referral to you? "I don't know. Like five people told me about you guys." But for me when I was ready to reach out to them what did I do? I went to Google, I typed in 'Connecticut Basement Systems', their, their profile, Google Profile came up.
[00:17:56] Bob Ruffolo: I saw the, the, um, like I said, I went to the [00:18:00] website, clicked the button. I didn't spend any time on their site. I knew of them and I just filled out the form. Very different experience but that's the brand identity that you're talking about and being the most known, trusted and recommended in your space
[00:18:12] Brian Casey: Yeah, and, and once you get someone to your site, this is-- it's related,
[00:18:22] Bob Ruffolo: Mm-hmm.
[00:18:22] Brian Casey: uh, but we're not gonna go down the rabbit hole. The goal is that they can learn the conclusion themselves and feel validated in it versus you telling them what they need to know.
[00:18:36] Bob Ruffolo: Tell me more about that
[00:18:37] Brian Casey: can... Yeah, I, it's kind of a preview of one of the things I'm talking about at EC live, but, I, I think you need to as a business earn the conclusion. Um, meaning, uh, uh, you can make a claim. You can say, "We're the best business in the world. We have the best people." Uh, [00:19:00] I'd like to have people reframe it as can you help someone come to that conclusion on their own? And can you earn their ability to do that
[00:19:10] Bob Ruffolo: Wow. What does that look like in practice?
[00:19:16] Brian Casey: Yeah, I mean if we tie this back to like the metrics piece that we're talking about um... People coming to your site have some sense as to who you are. They trust you at somewhat because they came to your site. Um, y-you have to capitalize on that by being real authentic. You can't have just blanket statements.
[00:19:38] Brian Casey: You have to define everything. You have to be specific. You have to be measurable. Uh, feel like I'm talking about SMART goals but like legitimately when you're talking about yourself as a business it's not good enough to say uh, the old SEO hack "best basement waterproofing company in this area." It has to have [00:20:00] those elements that you were kind of talking about; reviews reputation management. You have to talk about your process. You have to talk about what you do how you do it and who you're a good fit for all the things related to website then downstream you would see that because you'd have people interacting with more pages
[00:20:16] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:20:17] Brian Casey: out forms more often than your website drive your overall cost per lead down so again flywheel mindset ah, that's kind of the big new thing that I'm thinking about is don't make the claim or earn the conclusion
[00:20:32] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. You know, a- again this just goes back to even saying what we said before. Y- none of this works unless you have a good business. Um, you can put a headline on your website and this may had worked in maybe 2009 I don't know. Uh, best roofer in Knoxville Tennessee. And I'm speaking roofer in Knoxville Tennessee.
[00:20:52] Bob Ruffolo: We talk about roofers a lot here at, in the Endless Customer podcast. Best roofers in Knoxville Tennessee. Um, now [00:21:00] today if you actually wanna show up as the best roofer in Knoxville Tennessee you have to backup that claim is what Brian's saying here. And you have to think how can we back up that claim so that humans and robots but start with humans 'cause these robots try to think like humans So if you solve for the humans then you're gonna solve for the robots too.
[00:21:19] Bob Ruffolo: How do we prove that we actually are the best? So maybe right underneath that claim you have the best roofer in uh, Knoxville Tennessee awards that you've won five years in a row, right? 2026, 2025, 2024, 2023, 2022. All right well that's pretty good credibility like we're, we're going go take that right? Um, as long as it's a reputable awards company or you could say "We have the most reviews and the highest rating reviews and we generate more reviews every single month than anyone else."
[00:21:48] Bob Ruffolo: That's pretty good credibility backs it up an- and Brian you could probably say, "We don't have the reviews, we don't have the awards. What else do we have?" And go figure that out but you gotta bring that data and that [00:22:00] story into these claims. Uh, you were talking about the people. This is where my mind went with the people too is you know, you can write words; we have great people.
[00:22:09] Bob Ruffolo: But people are gonna... You know, an- and by the way AI can, can look at images and r- actually review websites e- even now ChatGPT can see videos. The more you have on your website showing your people, showing their credibility, showing their experience, uh, how long they been with the company. Have that in writing.
[00:22:26] Bob Ruffolo: Uh, show them in pictures. Show them having a good time. Show them in their uniform. Show them professional. Show them that they are enjoying their work and that they will solve for you and when you have them in videos the way they're talking to customers and, and, and explaining the experience you'll go through, that is again to your point how do you show we have great people?
[00:22:48] Bob Ruffolo: Prove we have great people not because you're shoving it down their throats but because people see that and be like, "Oh! Look at this culture. Look at these people they must love working there," [00:23:00] Right
[00:23:00] Brian Casey: Yeah, and just to piggyback on one thing you said, y-you mentioned you can't just throw up as a header on a page, "Best roofing company in Knoxville." Um, somewhere in the like vicinity of 6 to 12 months ago, you could do that, and AI would say they're the best because you use the direct words. And that to me border-- Like, that's just a hack more than anything else. And I think the mindset that we have to have, like as companies is like focus on the principles, focus on the foundation, the things that are always gonna be true. Don't chase the hack.
[00:23:35] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:23:35] Brian Casey: Don't chase the like, oh, I saw one company do this and they had wild success in generating a bunch of AI recommendations.
[00:23:43] Brian Casey: I'm gonna do the exact same thing. What you're speaking to is more foundational. It's more, uh, evergreen. It's more, uh, just sustainable over time. like if you, if you just think about it, it's like, is this a hack or is this the right thing to do? [00:24:00] Lean into the right thing to do to build trust
[00:24:03] Bob Ruffolo: You're, you're exactly right and that's, that's always been our philosophy here at IMPACT for, for forever because, you know, if you go ... Again going back to the early 2000s there was a thing called keyword stuffing. Well, you know it's not like Google wanted to reward companies for keyword stuffing. Right?
[00:24:19] Bob Ruffolo: They wanted to reward companies that were doing things the right way. And they wanted the best businesses to, to show up because the only way people would continue use Google is if they got value out of Google so if Google was presenting them the best stuff they needed they would keep using it, right?
[00:24:35] Bob Ruffolo: Um, so and of course as years went on it didn't last very long, the keyword stuffing. Google was able to get that completely out of everything then people stopped doing that. So yes, you might... To your point Brian I think yeah it was very, very smartly said. You may hear these things like oh this little hack or little thing that, that you know um if you do this in ChatGPT it doesn't understand it so if you do it will show you up more.
[00:24:57] Bob Ruffolo: It's like okay well until the next model [00:25:00] comes out and just like pfft now it doesn't work anymore. So but at the end of the day it's, these systems are only trying to think like humans more. They're only trying to make better recommendations and, and, and l-, and make the credible businesses show up, the legit businesses.
[00:25:19] Bob Ruffolo: So again that's why number one factor is you have to have a good business we keep going back to that. Um, I know this all about metrics and when I feel like we're going down a rabbit hole here but there's still metrics could be tracking here, right? It's ,you know, on the business level are we doing quality work?
[00:25:34] Bob Ruffolo: But on the, the marketing side of that how many awards are we applying for and how many reviews are we generating? So th- that could be some things that we-we're focusing on
[00:25:42] Brian Casey: And, and I think one of the, like, things to get out there, um, that people generally have a misconception of Endless Customers means you can't talk about yourself
[00:25:58] Bob Ruffolo: Hmm.
[00:25:59] Brian Casey: historically, we might [00:26:00] say: We're not gonna apply for awards. We don't wanna be boastful. We don't want to-- um, you know, Endless customers is not talking about us.
[00:26:09] Brian Casey: It's education, education, education. Um, I do think that the landscape has shifted. Like best of articles are a great example of like historically recommended "Don't put yourself on a Best Of article." Now you kind of have to ' cause
[00:26:23] Bob Ruffolo: Kaplan
[00:26:23] Brian Casey: be out of the conversation if you don't. And, and the question isn't, talk about ourselves? The question is, when someone asks a question about us, are we a part of the conversation or is everybody else dictating
[00:26:36] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:26:36] Brian Casey: the opinion of us? can we talk about ourselves in a way that is a 360 degree view on it versus being biased? And maybe that's the biggest piece of all of this is, um, how we talk about ourselves gives the impression that we wanna give
[00:26:52] Bob Ruffolo: You know, here's another possible metric off of what you just said. So obviously we just mentioned putting yourself on a best of list and you have to have [00:27:00] the quantitative reasons to, to why you belong on that list. But go to Google and type in who are the best blank in your market, right? Whatever it is.
[00:27:10] Bob Ruffolo: Um, wherever you want to be showing up, and then take an inventory of everything that's on that first page, and then put a percentage of how many of those pages are actually mentioning you. And then set a goal to say, "We wanna go from here to here. If only one's mentioning us, we wanna get four of these things mentioning us."
[00:27:27] Bob Ruffolo: That could be an initiative that you're focusing on. Then you have to say, "What do we have to do to get on those lists? Do we have to apply for it? Do we have to reach out to persons? Do we just have to ask? Do we... You know, will we never be on this list for whatever reason?" How do you do that? And then you can just go do the same thing with ChatGPT.
[00:27:41] Bob Ruffolo: Just go and say, "Hey, um, who are the best companies here?" And that's gonna give you all the answers. You may or may not be on the answers. What sources did you use, specifically any articles that listed these companies or directories? Um, w-- and then again, inventory all those, [00:28:00] and then increase your percentages.
[00:28:01] Bob Ruffolo: That would be a metric I would be focusing on
[00:28:03] Brian Casey: Yeah, so we don't generally like plug tools, but Microsoft Clarity is like a free-to-use tool, free for life non-rate limited. have AI visibility and they uh, have citation now in beta topic insights that basically tell you your topical authority on something. I think that's 100% a metric that you should be tracking is um, AI citations, AI recommendations, AI topic insight, and not because, um, AI is like this boon right now in terms of being a recommender. traffic from AI sources is still climbing. It's not, you know what Google was in its heyday. but mainly because it's a-- It's more in line with how people think. They're having more conversations with AI than historically you've typed into a Google search. so it's good visibility and insight as to how you are [00:29:00] performing relative to natural conversations that people would be having
[00:29:04] Bob Ruffolo: So that, that's very interesting. So I was-- Before we wrap up, I want to talk about AI visibility, um, and the metrics that you're tracking around that. Um, and I, I have some specific things I'm wondering, and I don't know if you guys do this or not, so I'm, I'm actually interested in some questions. But let's just start with that first one there.
[00:29:23] Bob Ruffolo: Um, AI visibility, what tools are you using, and what metrics are you tracking, uh, across most of your clients?
[00:29:30] Brian Casey: I am full bore Microsoft Clarity, um, in terms of the AI visibility because it's free and it's a really good tool.
[00:29:39] Bob Ruffolo: Okay, good
[00:29:41] Brian Casey: anybody that has HubSpot is gonna have some, uh, at whatever threshold, is gonna have some AI visibility built into it as well. I, I've not been recommending like bulkier, heavier, uh, tools that y- you know, cost more money. I'm looking into kind of the back end of a client [00:30:00] site right now, and I can see AI visibility, how many citations they're getting, what their share of authority is, how much referral traffic they're getting. It breaks it down by topical authority. Uh, your percentage of how well you perform in terms of the authority around the keywords that you rank for.
[00:30:18] Brian Casey: It shows your cited pages. Um, so Clarity is like an insanely good free tool
[00:30:25] Bob Ruffolo: Awesome. Now, um, here's where I want to go which is the, the interesting thing. So Stephanie and I just had an episode the other day And we were talking about, um, human traffic dropping for most p- business websites but AI bot traffic increasing across most websites. Um, of course that is AI researching your business and deciding whether or not it's going to recommend you or, um, answer a user's question based on your perspectives, your information in feeding that in.
[00:30:58] Bob Ruffolo: Are we able to track [00:31:00] this, this AI traffic and then the benefits of it? Because somebody may never even go to their website. They may say, "You know, I recommend you call this company and here's their phone number," and you just call them But the fact that AI took the time to go through your s-... When I say time, it took 'em 30 seconds To go through your entire website and read 50 pages and say, "Based on everything I researched you should call this company."
[00:31:22] Bob Ruffolo: Are we able to track that at all?
[00:31:24] Brian Casey: Yeah, so Clarity actually has a bot activity, um, tab as well where you can track how bots are using your website. I, I think it's gonna be even more difficult from an attribution standpoint.
[00:31:37] Bob Ruffolo: Oh, yeah
[00:31:38] Brian Casey: but, but I think like historically we have said like bot traffic is spam.
[00:31:43] Bob Ruffolo: Hmm. No, it's not.
[00:31:44] Brian Casey: around
[00:31:45] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:31:45] Brian Casey: traffic and so I think there's a reframing kind of a, uh, a new mindset around like bot traffic and bot traffic is like agents that are potentially researching and buying and, we have to, [00:32:00] to provide a good experience for them because I, I think it's a pretty feasible future where people are conversing with and agents are researching and recommending and that is the buyer's journey
[00:32:17] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. Yeah. That's where the world's going, my man. So let's, let's break this all down, and let's put the cherry on top of this episode. If you were to summarize the key things that you would be saying, and maybe the five or six things you say for al- all listeners, um, you should be tracking these things as part of your scorecard or your marketing metrics.
[00:32:41] Bob Ruffolo: Um, let's just summarize what those, you know, handful of metrics would be
[00:32:45] Brian Casey: Cost per lead, close rate, sales cycle time. I've said cycle time a couple times. It just
[00:32:53] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:32:54] Brian Casey: long does someone sit in your sales funnel
[00:32:56] Bob Ruffolo: Yep.
[00:32:57] Brian Casey: you make it quicker?
[00:32:58] Bob Ruffolo: Much, yeah. [00:33:00] Yep. Very, very important
[00:33:02] Brian Casey: Um, leads and the quality of those leads, so how many of those leads are coming in are qualified. Do they meet a certain quality threshold?
[00:33:12] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:33:12] Brian Casey: they score a certain threshold as a lead score, which you can track in tools like HubSpot. last one would be like website engagement metrics. Yeah. When, when you do get people to your site, they bouncing? Are they going to a, a bunch of pages? Are they spending time on your site? Do they convert
[00:33:32] Bob Ruffolo: So what I'm hearing here is a shift from having marketing metrics that prove that the marketing team handed a whole bunch of contacts over to the sales team to start working, versus the marketing team having more responsibility for sending really good ready-to-buy qualified sales opportunities that's easy for sales to close.
[00:33:53] Bob Ruffolo: That seems to be when you look at th-the difference in the marketing metrics, uh, that's a huge shift because if your website traffic's [00:34:00] going up, you're generating more contacts, more subscribers and all those metrics that we used to look at doesn't necessarily mean that you're winning more customers. So the scorecard has now evolved as marketing really getting the brand recommended more, um, by name and there's the trust there, there's the credibility there, there's the belief there, there's the, the education that got them sales right there always to point that they are like, "I am ready to buy and I want to talk to you so I can just finish this transaction."
[00:34:27] Bob Ruffolo: And having metrics and, and marketing activities that support that. That seems to be the, the difference between ... That's wha-what I'm taking from this conversation
[00:34:35] Brian Casey: Yeah, and I think there's an important distinction between like the stuff that list that I just went down is the result of doing everything like strategic that we talked about on the front end. Like those results aren't impacted if you don't build the business the right way, if you don't have a good reputation, if you don't uh, have the ability to prove
[00:34:56] Bob Ruffolo: Oh,
[00:34:57] Brian Casey: you do work. [00:35:00] so
[00:35:00] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:35:01] Brian Casey: related to like and education and mindset building trust,
[00:35:05] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:35:06] Brian Casey: hasn't changed It's more just the, the metrics may look different than they used to
[00:35:14] Bob Ruffolo: You know, it's funny you're saying that too, is like if you run your business like the '90s cable company and you... people show up and they are, you know, three hours late, and they come in like jerks, and they do a so-so job, and they leave, and you're frustrated, uh, that doesn't fly today. And, and if you start putting marketing into that, you're just amplifying the channels for people to say, "All right, so w- we're gonna just put an automated thing into our process where we're just gonna ask people for reviews, and we'll get more reviews."
[00:35:43] Bob Ruffolo: Well, you know, if you're not running a good business, you're not gonna have great reviews that people are going, you know, that's gonna make all this work. So, um, again, it all goes
[00:35:52] Brian Casey: one stat at you that I found recently? So in late 2025, uh, surveyed like 1,500 people, [00:36:00] and of them 68% frequently wonder whether content information they see is real
[00:36:07] Bob Ruffolo: Wow.
[00:36:09] Brian Casey: And I think that number's gonna continue to grow
[00:36:12] Bob Ruffolo: Oh, it only has to. Yeah. Yeah, if you're watching these videos that show up in reels and yeah I'm s-... And we live in this world, and I'm still like, "Is that real or not?" Wait, we had a story the other day here at IMPACT. Um, I found these, these videos I thought were really cool. It was this guy, um, he looked like he was from like the '60s or '70s, and he was giving sales advice.
[00:36:35] Bob Ruffolo: And I was like, oh my God, some of the best sales advice I ever saw, and I'm sending it off. I'meyer like" I don't know who this guy from the '60s or '70s is, but this so cool." And Tom's like, "Bobby, you know that's AI right?"I'm like nope, but now I do.
[00:36:48] Brian Casey: Yeah. So I think it just like validates everything we're talking about, like build the business the right way, as authentic as you can be, build as much trust as you can, earn the conclusion versus make the [00:37:00] claim. then we kind of walk through the handful of metrics that are gonna help you in 2026 and beyond understand how well that's working.
[00:37:09] Bob Ruffolo: Preach. Preach. Brian, this has, been a great episode. Uh, always love having you on. We'll have to have you on again real soon if you'll make the time for us. I know you're a busy guy. You got a lot of clients. You're doing great work, man. So thank you so much for being on the episode.
[00:37:25] Brian Casey: Happy to be here
[00:37:26] Bob Ruffolo: All right, well, this has been another episode of the Endless Customers Podcast.
[00:37:29] Bob Ruffolo: We will see you at the next episode
[00:37:31] Stephanie Baiocchi: If you liked this episode, please take a minute to leave us a review. Thanks for checking out the Endless Customers Podcast.
For most of IMPACT's history, the marketing scorecard started with traffic. More visitors meant more contacts, more contacts meant more sales, and we built the whole inbound playbook on that math.
AI broke the chain. We're seeing organic traffic drop across the board, and the question I keep hearing from clients is a fair one: if our traffic is falling, is our marketing failing?
To answer it, I sat down with Brian Casey, Senior Coach at IMPACT and one of my favorite Endless Customers coaches. Brian coaches home service, insurance, and manufacturing companies, and he's been rebuilding his clients' scorecards around this exact problem.
The five numbers Brian has clients track
Brian sees organic traffic regressing to the mean: companies that blogged heavily for years are losing traffic, while companies that never published are still gaining. Either way, he wants clients focused on bringing in non-paid buyers and sales.
- Cost per lead, broken out by channel, is the one he pushes hardest.
- Close rate shows whether buyers from your content and referrals close more often than buyers from ads.
- Sales cycle time asks how long someone sits in your sales process and whether you can shorten it.
- Lead volume and quality counts only the inquiries that clear a lead score threshold in a tool like HubSpot.
- Website engagement, meaning bounce rate, pages per session, and conversions, matters more now that fewer visitors arrive.
When Brian ran through that list, I heard a shift in what marketing is responsible for. The old metrics proved that marketing had handed sales a pile of contacts. Brian's list asks whether marketing sent buyers who were ready to buy, and that's a harder standard to meet.
Where Brian and I disagree
I'm not a fan of attribution because buyers have a hundred touchpoints and forget most of them. Brian agrees you'll never get the full picture, but he still values knowing your marketing's known impact on closed deals. As he put it, a caller who says "Google" could mean an organic result, an AI Overview, or just "online."
Earn the conclusion
Brian says you now have to be known for who you are and for what you do. He measures both with branded search in Search Console and AI citations in Microsoft Clarity. I added a metric of my own: count how many first-page "best of" results mention you.
A headline like "best roofer in Knoxville" stopped working, too. Buyers and AI want proof they can check, like awards by year, reviews, and real photos of your team. You have to put in the work to earn the conclusion.
Watch the full episode above, or listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your podcast platform of choice, to build a scorecard that shows whether your marketing is winning customers.
Connect with Brian
Brian Casey is a Senior Coach at IMPACT, where he helps home service, insurance, and manufacturing companies implement the Endless Customers System. He's known for a direct coaching style that puts fundamentals first, and he's coached teams at companies including Linta Roofing and Berry Insurance.
In this episode, he explains why he has clients judge their marketing by cost per lead, close rate, and sales cycle time, and why he uses Microsoft Clarity to track AI citations. He's also advised his alma mater, UNC Wilmington, since 2012.
Connect with Luke Wilson on LinkedIn: [LINK NEEDED: Luke's LinkedIn URL]Keep Learning- How to Create Content AI Can't Replicate (and is Worth Citing)
- How AI Makes Recommendations [2026 AI Visibility Report]
- How to Turn Sales Call Transcripts into a Content Engine
- AEO Best Practices: 5 Ways to Improve Your Brand's AI Visibility
__
Endless Customers is a podcast for business owners/leaders, marketers, creatives, and sales teams who want to build trust, attract the right buyers, and drive sustainable revenue growth.
Produced by IMPACT, a sales and marketing training organization, we help companies implement The Endless Customers System by focusing on the right strategies and actions that build trust, educate buyers, and generate more leads.
Interested in sponsorship opportunities or joining us as a guest? Email brand@impactplus.com.
Facing a challenge in your sales and marketing? Schedule a free coaching session with one of our experts and take the step toward business growth.
Posted On:
Oct 15, 2026
Topics:
Share
Subscribe to the Podcast
Get the latest Endless Customers Podcast episodes and practical lessons delivered to your inbox.