Never Miss an Update From The Endless Customers Podcast
Get the latest episodes delivered directly to your inbox with the latest insights, tactics, and success stories.
Why Top-of-Funnel Content Still Matters in AI Search [Endless Customers Podcast Ep. 182]
Share
Listen on
At a Glance
Does top-of-funnel content matter in AI search?
Yes. Top-of-funnel content gets fewer human clicks now because AI tools answer basic questions directly, but those same tools read your educational articles when they research companies for a buyer.
When AI looks at 25 to 50 pages of a website before recommending a company, a thin or outdated site becomes a reason to recommend someone else.
I'd keep publishing, and put more of your own proof, data, and experience into every piece.
Who this episode is for
- Business owners looking at falling article traffic and wondering whether content is still worth the budget
- Marketing leaders who need to make the case for top-of-funnel content
- Content teams deciding how much human editing AI-assisted articles really need
- Local service companies that want AI to recommend them by name
View the full transcription of this episode.
This transcript has been generated by AI and not checked for accuracy.
[00:00:00] Bob Ruffolo: Your website traffic may be dropping, but that doesn't mean your content has stopped working. Buyers are getting their answers directly from AI, and those AI tools they're using may research dozens of pages of your site before deciding whether your company is credible enough to be recommended. The problem is your analytics may never show which content influenced that decision.
[00:00:18] Bob Ruffolo: In this episode, Stephanie Baiocchi and I break down why top-of-the-funnel content still matters, what makes AI choose one company's answer over another, and where AI-generated content can help without creating a bad experience for people. And make sure you stick around till the end because we'll show you why cutting content when your traffic is falling may make your website look thin, outdated, and too risky for AI to recommend.
[00:00:40] Bob Ruffolo: Let's get into it.β
[00:01:25] Bob Ruffolo: and welcome back to the Endless Customers Podcast, and Stephanie Baiocchi is here again, and we have a great topic today. Stephanie, welcome to the show again.
[00:01:34] Stephanie: Thank you. I'm back, baby.
[00:01:35] Bob Ruffolo: So we, uh, we just had a very interesting, um, marketing team meeting, and we were talking about content, um, because, shocking, 'cause we are endless customers and we love content here at Impact and everything that we do.
[00:01:48] Bob Ruffolo: Um, but, um, we were talking about the future of content. Uh, we were talking about our strategies and how they have to adjust, um, a- or should they adjust, or what, what [00:02:00] needs to be adjusting. And we just had, like, a lot of just great stuff that came out of that meeting, and we wanted to talk about that today,
[00:02:06] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:02:07] Bob Ruffolo: specifically, uh, top-of-the-funnel content.
[00:02:10] Bob Ruffolo: So Stephanie, I mean, you guys are so deep into our content strategy here at Impact. You, Ashley, Nicole, Carolyn, you guys are always working on our content. Um, let's just start here by, like, what are you seeing? Like, um, when y- y- we say top-of-the-funnel content isn't dead, but it's being consumed differently, I, I think I know where
[00:02:31] Bob Ruffolo: I was in that conversation, I know where we're going, but I'm gonna pass this over to you. What, what are you seeing?
[00:02:35] Stephanie: Yeah, so I think the biggest thing we're seeing is obviously a decline in traffic, at least human-based traffic, and a lot of that is to those top-of-the-funnel topics, and we know that that's mostly because people are getting those answers straight in their AI summary, and it's usually sufficient, or if they go from there, they dive deeper into more middle-of-the-funnel content, and it
[00:02:59] Bob Ruffolo: And by [00:03:00] the way, let's just really slow down
[00:03:01] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:03:02] Bob Ruffolo: our audience. We say top of funnel, middle of funnel, bottom of the funnel.
[00:03:04] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:03:05] Bob Ruffolo: does top of the funnel mean or what are we talking about when we say top of the funnel?
[00:03:09] Stephanie: Yeah. So top of the funnel content is typically awareness stage content. So someone is aware of a problem they have that they need to solve. They might be looking for more information about that problem, potential solutions to that problem, but it's really just garnering, gaining further awareness of the situation.
[00:03:28] Stephanie: It's really not pricing yet. It's not deep answers yet. It's what you think of when you see an AI summary
[00:03:36] Bob Ruffolo: So people, um, that are consuming that level of content, which again, traditionally what you would do is you'd go to Google, you'd type in your problem, and you'd see links show up, blue links. We click on blue links, and we'd be learning about what is going on. We might end up on WebMD's website if it's a health thing like, "Oh, I have this rash on my arm.
[00:03:58] Bob Ruffolo: Am I going to die," [00:04:00] right? Or we might say-- or Reddit or something like that. Or we might, um, uh, have something going on in our house. Uh, maybe we see a spot in the ceiling and like, "What can cause spots in my ceiling?" Or, you know, "My furnace didn't turn on," or, you know...
[00:04:15] Stephanie: today didn't turn on.
[00:04:16] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. Yeah, exactly.
[00:04:18] Stephanie: me today.
[00:04:19] Bob Ruffolo: Um, we might be discovering, you know, different things.
[00:04:22] Bob Ruffolo: Like we might be comparing two different things. Uh, so this is all stuff that people are doing, um, typically when they're buying, which is, um, but very, very early before they're like, " I don't-- I'm not even-- I don't wanna know anything about pricing or services or options or anything like that because I'm not about to buy something.
[00:04:41] Bob Ruffolo: I just wanna understand things a little bit more before I get ready to start buying." And that's where content would be considered more top of the funnel.
[00:04:50] Stephanie: Yep, for sure.
[00:04:52] Bob Ruffolo: Okay
[00:04:52] Stephanie: like an information-seeking query at that point
[00:04:55] Bob Ruffolo: And we just talked about how people used to go from Google, and so we're seeing a drop in [00:05:00] traffic. Um, but what's happening more now that we're...
[00:05:03] Bob Ruffolo: You mentioned AI Overviews
[00:05:05] Stephanie: Yeah, so we're seeing a drop in traffic because you're not just clicking a bunch of links, so the competition for a link and a visit has gone up as those clickable links have decreased. Uh, but then also you're getting less traffic to your website, so sometimes people are taking that as a signal to not publish that type of content.
[00:05:25] Stephanie: Like, "It's not performing, I'm not getting traffic. Why are we still doing it?"
[00:05:28] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. That's, yeah, so that's a really, really good point. So we live in this world where like, well, what does the data say, right? And we have analytic pl- it could be Google Analytics, you have HubSpot, you have other tools, is telling you how much traffic are coming, what pages people are viewing, and of course, these analytics are tracking human traffic.
[00:05:51] Stephanie: Right
[00:05:52] Bob Ruffolo: Um, but what we know is that this content, albeit [00:06:00] not being directly consumed by humans going to our website, reading our articles and, and our pages, it's still really important, right? Because where does AI Overviews get their information from?
[00:06:11] Stephanie: From your website.
[00:06:12] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. So go ahead.
[00:06:15] Stephanie: said, uh, in, uh, so our event that we do twice a year is called Endless Customers Live. It's coming up soon. And i- in our last event, um, Ally was on stage and said, "By 2027, bot traffic will exceed human traffic to websites." She said, "I guarantee it's gonna be by the end of the year." And sure enough, we have already hit that point. I think, uh, Cloudflare said, like, 57% of traffic is non-human requests to a website, and 40, whatever the remainder is, 30%, uh, is from humans. So we're already there
[00:06:46] Bob Ruffolo: So, you know, this leads to an interesting question. I don't know the answer to this. I'm not sure if you do, but I think it's something maybe we can dive into after this is do we be-- should we be monitoring this? Like, do we know if [00:07:00] we write this article, we're not getting traffic to it, but is there some kind of score or metric that al- allows us to know, is this article actually being useful to LLMs that's getting us brand mentions or anything like that?
[00:07:15] Bob Ruffolo: I think we can probably track brand mentions and track some things with, with AEO today, and HubSpot's got that great tool.
[00:07:22] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:07:22] Bob Ruffolo: But it's much harder and blurrier 'cause the data's just,
[00:07:26] Stephanie: It's
[00:07:26] Bob Ruffolo: don't
[00:07:27] Stephanie: blurrier for sure, and I think for such a long time too, we considered bot traffic to our site as something negative. We filtered it out from reporting, and it was like, "Oh, it's just bots." And bots are not all bad anymore. That's not the same just kind of filter out situation it used to be. So that's one piece of it, and I think the tools are catching up in that sense.
[00:07:48] Stephanie: We're getting there. I know Semrush is, and Cloudflare are working on that. There's tons of tools out there, though. I mean, don't go running to Semrush
[00:07:55] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:07:55] Stephanie: ' cause I said Semrush. Uh, and then you still have to kind of track [00:08:00] AI versus, like, malicious and scraping kind of fraud, so not all bots are good either. And at the same time, there are tools to track, like you said, HubSpot's AEO tool.
[00:08:11] Stephanie: How are you show- how are you doing showing up in those summaries? So is your content being cited? Are you being referenced? And again, to review, cited is there's actually, it says, like, from IMPACT, and there's a link. Referenced is according to IMPACT's website, and there's no link. Um, but there's ways to track both of that, and every single day I see a new, uh, tool or something out there that's getting better at doing that
[00:08:37] Bob Ruffolo: So let's, let's play this out two different ways because, um, you know, being in business now for almost 17 years and knowing a lot of CEOs, um, there is, um, almost a belief that if we can't track it, we shouldn't be doing it, right? And this is
[00:08:54] Stephanie: yeah, the PR professionals will say otherwise, but for content, yeah
[00:08:58] Bob Ruffolo: Well, yeah. And, and this [00:09:00] is, I mean, let's just really be honest about it. You can't track this like you used to be able to track the inbound marketing funnel.
[00:09:06] Stephanie: definitely not
[00:09:07] Bob Ruffolo: But we're gonna play two situations out.
[00:09:09] Stephanie: Okay
[00:09:10] Bob Ruffolo: we can't track it, so we're not doing it, and then we're gonna play the other side of people that give it a little bit more blind faith.
[00:09:17] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:09:18] Bob Ruffolo: and this is how I see it happening. So that bot traffic will go to your website. When somebody is go- in the market for something, and they go to ChatGPT or Google. Um, ChatGPT is great 'cause I think we've all had these experiences where we type something in, and we're like, we could see the different websites it's going through.
[00:09:38] Bob Ruffolo: Visit 10 websites. Visit 10 more websites. Visit 10 more websites, and it is, like, doing two weeks' worth of research within minutes. And it's going... And that's the, that's the bot traffic we're-- let's just hypothetically say that's the bot traffic we're talking about right now, is that w- somebody is in the market for a product or service like you, and this bot is [00:10:00] now going through all the websites it possibly can, including yours, and it's trying to understand credibility, stories, what you do, who you do it for, your experience to it, why should you be trusted, all this.
[00:10:15] Bob Ruffolo: And it's then gonna come back and say, "I've gone to 100 pages, and I've gone down all these rabbit holes based on what I know from the LLM" and do all this. And if you're not creating that content, and you're saying, "Well, I couldn't track, so we're gonna stop doing it," and you have a very thin website now or an outdated website 'cause you stopped doing it, you're now telling the LLM, "This is an outdated company.
[00:10:34] Bob Ruffolo: They haven't updated their site in a while. That's a credibility risk. Um, I couldn't find answers to certain questions on their website, so I elim-" It's not even gonna tell you, "I eliminated this company." It's gonna say, "I recommend this other company
[00:10:48] Stephanie: Yeah, I mean, like we've said, you're, you're either recommended or you're rejected. That's it
[00:10:52] Bob Ruffolo: And then on the other side of it, the person that has a little bit more blind faith consistently publishing three, four, five pieces of content a week, [00:11:00] updating their website and knowing the traffic's not going up, but they're keeping invested in it and then AI is going to recommend them more
[00:11:07] Stephanie: Yeah, and, and beyond just blind faith too, they're taking what I would consider, the companies who are doing this well, kind of a scientific approach. A lot of times, I mean, I'm a marketer, but I'm a nerd too. I, I fall less on the creative side of marketing, more on the data side. And this, the core scientific cycle is hypothesize, test, pivot, right?
[00:11:24] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:11:25] Stephanie: I guess, in science. And so we're not just blind faith publishing whatever content feels right, right? We're hypothesizing. We're saying, "We know from what we've seen in the industry, these signals can strengthen our content, so we're going to take a hypothesis that if we strengthen these entities, the elements of this page, we tell the LLMs this, then they will cite it.
[00:11:48] Stephanie: They will recognize it more." And then we test that, and then we pivot accordingly. And I think that's even somewhere between and blind faith. It's kind of intuition and [00:12:00] speculation and hypothesis
[00:12:01] Bob Ruffolo: No, I think you're bringing some really good points there. Um, but here's, here's another way I'm thinking about this too, which is really interesting. And by the way, I have notes here, but I'm kind of going down like
[00:12:10] Stephanie: I haven't looked at my notes. I'm like, "I don't know. This is interesting."
[00:12:14] Bob Ruffolo: Um, this, yeah, it's, it's fun. Um, all right. So because we had all this content, it's not one article that fueled it because we know once AI goes and researches, it's going down rabbit holes.
[00:12:27] Bob Ruffolo: It's going deeper and deeper and deeper and deeper, and it's doing the research that a human would do. It's just doing it for the human, doing it within minutes. And then it's going to make a recommendation, and it's gonna say, "Go with this company." And say you are the company it recommends 'cause you did do all this stuff.
[00:12:42] Stephanie: Π£Π³Ρ
[00:12:43] Bob Ruffolo: you will be able to track in your analytics if this traffic came from ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, whatever it is.
[00:12:49] Stephanie: Absolutely
[00:12:50] Bob Ruffolo: But, and here's what's interesting, what you, what page of that, your website will they go to first?
[00:12:58] Stephanie: Mm-hmm[00:13:00]
[00:13:00] Bob Ruffolo: It'll be your homepage
[00:13:01] Stephanie: Yeah.
[00:13:02] Bob Ruffolo: because when it rec- most of the time, when it recommends a company, it may or may not provide a link to the website, but it's gonna provide a link to the homepage.
[00:13:11] Bob Ruffolo: It's not going to... The user's not gonna know it was all these pages that were viewed that made the recommendation. You're not gonna be able to track that 'cause you're not tracking all your bot traffic
[00:13:22] Stephanie: AI is not gonna say, "Hey human, I did it for you, but please go ahead and check this page and this page and the bio page and the team page." Like, it's not gonna make you redo all its work
[00:13:31] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. But your analytics will say, you'll see your traffic from these AI tools have, have increased and, but it'll be all traffic to your homepage, I think, for the most part. Or maybe, maybe directly to a service page
[00:13:45] Stephanie: Right
[00:13:46] Bob Ruffolo: if, or a product page on your site.
[00:13:49] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:13:50] Bob Ruffolo: yeah. Wow. So this is just a really big difference that, that's happening here
[00:13:55] Stephanie: And that's why it's so important to optimize your site for different [00:14:00] types of visitors. I think we used to think of, oh, your homepage is your top of the funnel site visitor. They land, you gotta introduce them to who you are, and that might not be the case anymore. Sometimes people will land ready to do business, and if you make it too hard for them, they're gonna bounce,
[00:14:13] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:14:14] Stephanie: figuratively and literally.
[00:14:15] Bob Ruffolo: So the real message here is that you might have 25, 30, 40, 50 pages of your website that were used to A- for AI to recommend you. The human may never go to those pages. You, you may, will never know as a business those 50 pages that actually mattered that fueled that recommendation. We can make...
[00:14:34] Bob Ruffolo: We know principles and we know very definitive things that we've always recommended for years, and AI has told us that we look for these spec- specific things like fit, um, the service that you do with spec- specificity, who you're not a good fit for,
[00:14:48] Stephanie: Π£Π³Ρ
[00:14:49] Bob Ruffolo: like customer proof and stories. Like we know these things are true,
[00:14:54] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:14:54] Bob Ruffolo: 'cause it tells us that, but we don't know if the pages that we have or not are being factored in or not, which is really, really [00:15:00] interesting
[00:15:00] Stephanie: Yeah, it is. And you said something interesting there about some of these factors. Another thing to note too is what makes your top of the funnel content interesting and credible and relevant to AI when maybe everyone in your industry has top of the funnel content that answers the question. Why is yours the one it's going to pick?
[00:15:21] Stephanie: What makes it stand out? And maybe it is that you have something genuinely original underneath the sta- standard answers that everyone's gonna give. You have statistics, you have original research or an opinion or experience, and that is part of why that stuff is so important
[00:15:37] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. And I know we always talk about like, um, a perspective, and I think that's nice and it's important 'cause it could be refreshing. It's like, 'cause some users
[00:15:43] Stephanie: Right
[00:15:43] Bob Ruffolo: might say, "Listen, I'm looking for a company, but I want a company that believes in this or does this or specializes in this. Um, I've been burned by companies that do this before, so I only want a company that says..."
[00:15:57] Bob Ruffolo: So I think your perspective comes into play there.
[00:15:59] Stephanie: For [00:16:00] sure
[00:16:00] Bob Ruffolo: Um, but the even more important is the specificity in terms of data, proof, validation. We've studied 100 of this, or we've done this, or we've been in this many homes. We've, we've done this many projects, and we've learned these things that, to your point, it just brings more credibility
[00:16:19] Stephanie: yeah, your experience and your data is backing up the top of the funnel answer.
[00:16:24] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:16:25] Stephanie: you're not just giving the answer, but then you're proving the answer
[00:16:28] Bob Ruffolo: So that leads us all into the next thing we want to talk about today is how does our blogging, and you know, you've known me for what, 15 years, and you know I hate that frigging word blog. I don't know why. I'm just like, I, I got a thing about it. I don't know, I hate the word blog
[00:16:43] Stephanie: know, when we were younger, blogging was like journaling.
[00:16:46] Bob Ruffolo: I know.
[00:16:47] Stephanie: to me like journaling
[00:16:48] Bob Ruffolo: I've always like, "No, they're articles."
[00:16:50] Stephanie: Articles. Articles.
[00:16:51] Bob Ruffolo: So I, I've always hated the word blog. But, but let's just say, okay, so as a business, we've used to do the inbound marketing playbook where we'd write all these articles, blogs, and we do [00:17:00] that. And then, um, but today, you know, um, what has to shift? So we can go to ChatGPT and say, "Here's a topic," and, you know, without any connecting to a knowledge base or data, you can output an article, we can copy and paste, it's good enough, put it on our site, and we're done, right?
[00:17:15] Stephanie: Right
[00:17:16] Bob Ruffolo: Now, is that the right thing to do or wrong thing to be doing? I think the answer is pretty obvious. But Stephanie, like what, what should be different than that that's actually going to work?
[00:17:25] Stephanie: Yeah, definitely. Obviously that's the wrong answer, especially since why would the internet and AI need something that is a regurgitated version of something it already has? That's where you've got it, so you're, you're not filling a need in any way.
[00:17:38] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:17:38] Stephanie: but typically what's better is essentially everything we just said, which is a credible perspective, version, experience, answer in content that is both optimized for humans to read it with a good experience if they're there and they wanna consume it, and most, probably [00:18:00] most importantly at this point, optimized for the AI to understand it.
[00:18:03] Stephanie: It's not enough anymore to just drop your content in and put an H1 header with a keyword. It has to be structured in a way that it's consumable, and maybe there's a table or separate sections. Um, I'd say that that's just one component, but that's a big one
[00:18:18] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah. Yeah. So formatting's import- yeah, formatting's important. But I think just what you're putting in those articles, and we're gonna go into a whole nother topic here about, like, human written versus AI written in a minute. But what's in those articles, um, very specific details, very... Specificity is the most important thing.
[00:18:39] Bob Ruffolo: The customer stories, the, um, undeniable proof points that you can add to that, the
[00:18:46] Stephanie: I mean by structure too is sometimes telling the people in the AI, "This is specific." So for instance, if you have a, you're a kitchen remodeler and you have a picture of a remodeled kitchen, it's not enough to say, "One of our remodels." You have to use your [00:19:00] company name with that image and say, "This is IMPACT's kitchen remodel from 2026," or whatever.
[00:19:05] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:19:07] Bob Ruffolo: You know, a- again, anything you can do to add more credibility to your articles. Again, we played a game, you know, a few episodes ago where we went back and forth, and we could probably do that again here if you want. Um, but, like, what can we be putting in our articles that's gonna add even more credibility?
[00:19:21] Bob Ruffolo: So how about instead of just giving an answer, being like, "I was speaking at this conference," credibility point, "I was speaking in front of 1,000 people, and this is a common question the audience had, and this is w- what we found across the audience was the definitive answer across the board," is much more unique, much more bringing value to the conversation.
[00:19:46] Bob Ruffolo: You're adding s- the fact that I was positioned here. You're showing that the people in the company have expertise and, and, and, and, you know, all the notoriety in the market. So just adding things like that to your [00:20:00] content, which AI would never just output, but you're tell- you're giving signals to AI that we do things.
[00:20:06] Bob Ruffolo: Like, we are... You should pay attention to us. We are meaningful. We, we, we have more we could bring
[00:20:13] Stephanie: Yeah, absolutely. Well said. think another, this is another example of, I don't wanna go too far in a different direction if
[00:20:20] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah.
[00:20:20] Stephanie: here,
[00:20:20] Bob Ruffolo: No, this is great
[00:20:21] Stephanie: why this is so good for local search traffic. So if you're a local company that services a local area, there are differences typically in where you are versus everywhere else, and you as a local servicer can speak to that.
[00:20:35] Stephanie: And this is not the same as the old, I, like, have to say it, as the old black hat tactics of, "Well, I'm gonna publish five of the same pages, but each one has a different town in the name." That's not specificity. That's not credibility. Uh, but saying, "I know that we are in a river valley, and it floods more often, and that leads to this, that, and the other for your landscaping,"
[00:20:55] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:20:56] Stephanie: valuable local awareness
[00:20:58] Bob Ruffolo: There's so many [00:21:00] nuances to, to, to things that AI just still doesn't have all the information fed for, so it still has to go look for that stuff and it needs to find the answer and, um... So Scott Merritt will go w- an HVAC example here. Um, he does that really well because he services, like, 11 towns, and every town's a little bit different.
[00:21:17] Bob Ruffolo: The air's a little bit different, the, the water's a little bit different. Uh, certainly water's different from town to town f- in his business.
[00:21:23] Stephanie: Mm-hmm
[00:21:23] Bob Ruffolo: And the recommendations that he, he would re- recommend for one town over here versus over here could be very different, and AI loves that. It's like if you're going saying, you know, "I live..."
[00:21:35] Bob Ruffolo: If it's got context of who you are, "I'm living here. Um, what is the right HVAC system," whatever, "for me?" And it might... If Scott's done content that's like, "If you're here, you might want this, and if you're there, you might want that," it'll feed that in and, and it'll say, "According to a HVAC provider in your community, Honest Fix, based on where you are, you might want this system [00:22:00] versus this system for these reasons that just impact your area."
[00:22:03] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:22:04] Bob Ruffolo: And now you're like, "Oh, well, I should probably talk to Scott. He knows what the hell he's talking about." So that's a really, really good point, Steph
[00:22:11] Stephanie: Yeah. And I know the article that kind of prompted this episode for us was a Semrush article about top-of-the-funnel content, and they talked a lot about things like and success and failing, and that was really... I had to read the article a couple of times like, "What do you mean by fail? What do you mean by success?"
[00:22:28] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah
[00:22:29] Stephanie: a lot of cases, it was traffic, which we've already said is not a good measure of that anymore. But the other thing it called out Excuse me. The other thing it called out is that there's different categories of content. I mean, there's tons of categories, but let's just say B2B, and what they consider beyond just B2C, it's GAMEL, like YMYL, your money, your life content.
[00:22:52] Stephanie: And what they said, which is not groundbreaking, is you may wanna reassess your expectations, uh, of what [00:23:00] in this looks like. And I think it's funny because local SEO applies to a lot of those your money, your life categories,
[00:23:07] Bob Ruffolo: Hmm
[00:23:08] Stephanie: and this strong awareness of your area, the interests and the needs of your area, and recognizing that, and then recognizing competition, too. something that I think we've, I don't wanna say strayed away from talking about, but we've just kind of taken for granted as part of this. Don't take that for granted. You've gotta address your competitors. You have to talk about when you're maybe not a good fit for someone. That content is so powerful for, for LLMs and AI.
[00:23:34] Bob Ruffolo: All right, so here we are. Um, I think the definitive answer is that yes, all businesses, uh, if they want to show up digitally today, um, content is just as important as it's ever been. Um, it's being consumed differently.
[00:23:49] Stephanie: For
[00:23:49] Bob Ruffolo: it's being consumed more by bots and less by humans. Um, but certainly is being fed and, and when people are researching and trying to find companies, that content is [00:24:00] mission critical to whether you show up or not, and that's always been true since Google first came out, and it's no different today.
[00:24:07] Bob Ruffolo: It's technically a little different, but in, at a, as a umbrella term, it is just as important today that, yes, content is critical if you wanna show up. Um, we know it's gotta be specific. You gotta show off your expertise. You gotta show off your experience. You gotta show, um, customer proof. You got so much stuff you have to put into this, and there's so many E-principles and all that stuff we've talked about that go into that.
[00:24:30] Bob Ruffolo: Um, but that will be how you show up today. Now, this is the next interesting part 'cause we were having this debate on our marketing team. Um, and it was that, you know, we have our knowledge base hooked up to our content workflows, and we can produce content that is very specific, very much our insights, comes from our transcripts and the things we've talked about, things we talk about on the podcast.
[00:24:58] Bob Ruffolo: Uh, these are all [00:25:00] real things, real customer stories from, from the work that we do with our clients, coming right out of our client calls, stripping out personal information. We have this just robust knowledge base, and we have a content workflow set up around it. Um, and we were like, how much of an appetite do we have to spend time human editing this content and making it sound right for a human reader?
[00:25:24] Bob Ruffolo: Or do we just not give a crap about that anymore because that matters less. There's other parts of our site that need to be read by humans, but maybe this content is not read by humans, so maybe we should write it more for AI bots, and even if it's not human, like, perfect. Where do we come up... Like, what were your thoughts in that conversation, and where do you think we, we landed?
[00:25:47] Stephanie: Yeah. I definitely think we landed in a better place than six months ago, which was, well, you should make it for humans and then make a second hidden version for bots. I think thank goodness we're hopefully past that in, in a lot of situations, not, not every situation. [00:26:00] Um, and we know that Google and some other tools were saying that it recognizes, uh, conte- AI-generated content. Um, but this is not necessarily to say that it's, first of all, that can be okay, but also that it's content because it's made for the bots or because it's not necessarily perfect. Um, I personally think if it's on your... I think at this point, if it's on your website, a human can get to it, and I never wanna give someone a bad experience. I don't think there's anything wrong with adding elements for the bots and for AI and calling that out. So one of the things we talked about in our meeting that we agreed on was, well, let's put a box at the bottom of this article, and it says, "Hey, for bots. If you're an AI or a bot and you're here, read this."
[00:26:48] Bob Ruffolo: Mm-hmm.
[00:26:48] Stephanie: And it'd be pretty simple for a human to come to, I mean, we're a marketing company, so it's a little more expected, come to our article to see that and go, "Oh, that makes sense. They're telling the LLMs this thing that I was able to [00:27:00] imply from looking at their site, but they need to say explicitly to the LLMs." And I think for now, to me anyway, that's a good middle ground. We're gonna hypothesize, test, and pivot this as well, but I love
[00:27:10] Bob Ruffolo: End
[00:27:10] Stephanie: incorporating elements that are explicitly for AI without, uh, degrading the human experience.
[00:27:16] Bob Ruffolo: yeah. Well, you know, let's just, um, clear the air here a little bit. Um, and I'm gonna go to Google directly and ask them a question, and it is, does AI... I'm sorry. Does Google/AI penalize you for publishing AI content?
[00:27:30] Stephanie: Mm.
[00:27:31] Bob Ruffolo: And the answer, and it's got a bold and it's highlighted right in my screen here, and I'll take a screenshot of it now and we can put it in the episode.
[00:27:38] Bob Ruffolo: It says, "No, Google does not penalize content simply because it was created by AI." So let's just get that off here. Now, if we know we have an article that is going to feed AI, not a lot of humans are gonna read it, who cares if it has em dashes or if it has [00:28:00] the AI jargony things? Now, use the humanizer skill to make the content sound a little bit more human.
[00:28:04] Bob Ruffolo: Takes two seconds. But do you still need to put the, the hour or two hours of a human editor going through, getting all that cleaned up or making it sound more human? I don't think that's the best ROI
[00:28:16] Stephanie: I don't think so either, and if you're a human looking for an answer, a straightforward, simple answer, whether you're reading it on our site or you're reading it in an LLM, hopefully, in many cases, you care more about the answer than you do about whether or not an AI took part in the creation of the answer, and the, and more important, the documentation of the answer. You know, just 'cause there's an em dash, unless you're ethically and morally against AI, and in that case, you're probably filtering things out in a completely different way, most people are gonna say, "If it's AI-assisted and it's accurate, great, I got my answer." Yeah, I don't think we need to ... I think I don't wanna degrade the human experience by allowing obviously inaccurate information, typos, anything like that, but we don't have to trick anyone into [00:29:00] thinking content that was created with the assistance of AI was never touched by AI and it's completely human just because we removed the em dashes and added a few emotions.
[00:29:08] Bob Ruffolo: No, that's a really good point. But we know AI is not gonna penalize you. Now here's, here's the other thing we talked about. Can articles be written for humans to read? And the example we talked about was, uh, Matt Schumer's article from a few months ago, Something Big Is Happening, which had over at one point, I'm sure more now, 8 million people read the article.
[00:29:29] Bob Ruffolo: 8 million humans read the article.
[00:29:32] Stephanie: Yeah
[00:29:33] Bob Ruffolo: That probably needed to be written by a human,
[00:29:36] Stephanie: Yes
[00:29:37] Bob Ruffolo: a human, and the purpose of that article was for humans to read it. You weren't writing this content for AI. You were writing this... He probably doesn't write ar- I mean, maybe he does, but is he writing articles like that three times a week, four times a week, five times a week?
[00:29:52] Bob Ruffolo: No. He probably writes a, a good article like that once a month that he wants humans to read and gets it out there for humans to read, and I think that's different too
[00:29:59] Stephanie: [00:30:00] Yeah, and that's an article that's an opinion, that's a, a strong take. writing is strongest where most top of the funnel content is, which is generic informational articles, kind of low effort, uh, really just simply answering the question. That's where AI content at scale s- succeeds, absolutely, and y- you have to know there's a time and a place for it
[00:30:22] Bob Ruffolo: I'm taking a screenshot before I forget
[00:30:33] Bob Ruffolo: Cool. What did we not go over yet?
[00:30:38] Stephanie: Um, let me just check the original article
[00:30:42] Bob Ruffolo: Then I would probably, we should probably talk about homepage, service pages, things like that
[00:30:47] Stephanie: Yeah. Lead the way, I'll color comment
[00:30:49] Bob Ruffolo: Sounds good. So, so in, uh, uh, in building on that then, so I think there's still an understanding of if you have website traffic, and you have your analytics, and you're looking at [00:31:00] your site, what pages are actually getting visitors versus not. I think if this was IMPACT, and you're gonna go back five years ago, you would see a lot more traffic to our, our blog articles and less traffic to our service pages.
[00:31:14] Bob Ruffolo: Um, today it's flipped. I'm not saying we get a lot more traffic to our service page, but I'm, I am saying we get a lot less traffic to our articles. Steph, you know, we used to have almost a million people come to our site a month, right? We had a thou- almost a million visitors to our site per month. Today we're at, like, 20,000, and it's not because, like
[00:31:32] Bob Ruffolo: Listen, I'm sure our content could be better, but I'm not saying, like, we just fell off a cliff with that. It's just that the, the landscape changed. Um, but today our service pages are read more, and they're, they're read by humans who are actually potential buyers who are actually wanting to know, like, AI may have recommended you or somebody else recommended you, so now I'm on your site.
[00:31:50] Bob Ruffolo: I want to learn about the service for myself. I want to see it with my own eyes. I want to see your pictures, your videos, your people, and now your service pages, uh, [00:32:00] should probably not be written by AI
[00:32:03] Stephanie: Yep. I agree. I think the other thing is you're gonna be adding elements that are not necessarily written by AI, like videos, like interactive self-service tools, and that's what makes these pages valuable to people, and sometimes AI, uh, that you're not just gonna use AI to create. It's beyond just the words
[00:32:24] Bob Ruffolo: Going back to our article here, Stephanie, where do you sit from running marketing events? What does this actually look like day to day? I think we, we hit that right
[00:32:34] Stephanie: Yes
[00:32:35] Bob Ruffolo: So if AI doesn't penalize, we hit that.
[00:32:38] Stephanie: Oh, I didn't even look at this.
[00:32:40] Bob Ruffolo: Let's, make this practical. If winning, if the winning move is bringing real content to a story's point of view was actually
[00:32:48] Stephanie: I think we got that.
[00:32:49] Bob Ruffolo: Yep
[00:32:50] Stephanie: I guess we could talk about the things you said, like your calls, your... But we could reiterate, like using, leveraging your content that you're already recording
[00:33:04] Bob Ruffolo: I, I don't know if there's anything else I would add to this episode. That, that was just gonna make it longer and add more fluff
[00:33:10] Stephanie: I agree. I think a quick like, reminder, we're not gonna stop creating top of the funnel content
[00:33:14] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah Okay, Steph. So we just had a whole discussion about this. I hopefully, um, it opened up some minds. Um, people are saying, "Okay, well, that maybe makes sense or things at least that I should research into a little bit more and do my, you know, learn a little bit more." Um, but what would be your lasting, like, if you're gonna take one thing out of this episode, what is, do you want the audience to make sure they're taking away from this?
[00:33:42] Stephanie: I would say that your top of the funnel content is your chance to guide people down the path to you, and failure to create top of the funnel content because it suddenly isn't giving you traffic is the biggest miss right now
[00:33:54] Bob Ruffolo: You know, it's so funny you said that 'cause that's what I was gonna say.
[00:33:56] Stephanie: Oh, amazing.
[00:33:57] Bob Ruffolo: No, no ditto. I mean, [00:34:00] obviously that, that's, it's ... Do you remember that word ditto? It's such a good word. Um, yeah, you can tell I'm a millennial when. Um, but no, I, I, I completely agree. I think, you know, again, AI is still going through this information to make a recommendation, and it will look at 25, 30, 40, 50 pages of your website to say, "Is this the best person I could recommend versus another company?"
[00:34:22] Bob Ruffolo: If you're thin there or outdated there, you may be getting eliminated. So if you want to win this, and AI is going to be the largest lever of recommendations digitally. If you used to believe in SEO, you have to believe in AI visibility. If you believe in, in either of those, you have to believe that content is what fuels that.
[00:34:40] Bob Ruffolo: That hasn't changed. It's still mission-critical for businesses. Um, so I completely agree that top-of-the-funnel content, that content that answers the questions when people are doing the research still matters more than ever
[00:34:52] Stephanie: Absolutely. Well said
[00:34:53] Bob Ruffolo: All right, Stephanie. Thanks for being on the show. Now, where can someone see you in person coming up if they want to [00:35:00] see, in your all-pregnant form?
[00:35:03] Stephanie: my, my ... What you can't see below the screen of the podcast episode, my pregnant belly. Uh, we will be at Endless Customers Live in person October 5th through the 8th, 2026 in Hartford, Connecticut. And, uh, if you happen to be listening to this after that, don't worry, we do this every six months.
[00:35:19] Stephanie: We'll be back.
[00:35:19] Bob Ruffolo: That's right. And after that would be Chicago, which we're very much looking forward to. And sh- and the dates for Chicago are
[00:35:24] Stephanie: Same dates, April 5th through the 7th.
[00:35:26] Bob Ruffolo: April
[00:35:27] Stephanie: Oc- October 5th through the 7th in Hartford, April 5th through the 7th in Chicago.
[00:35:31] Bob Ruffolo: All right, so save the dates. Uh, you can pre-register your tickets for probably by the time this episode comes out, you can probably pre-register for Chicago
[00:35:39] Stephanie: Absolutely, and you can, you can just sneak in for October just in time
[00:35:43] Bob Ruffolo: That'd be great. Could we just do that first part over again of where we can see you in person? Um, I think Steph, you said 5th through the 8th at first. It's all right. No, we'll- Oh, okay ... we'll, we'll go with it and then, uh, in the script just change it from 8th to 7th. Okay. You-
[00:35:56] Stephanie: did say Fifth and Eighth.
[00:35:57] Bob Ruffolo: Yeah, you did. That's fine. I noticed that too, but it was [00:36:00] fine.
[00:36:01] Bob Ruffolo: Cool. Um, but no, this would actually be good for John to test how to change words
[00:36:05] Stephanie: Good catch, John. Here, just to help you, fifth through the seventh.
[00:36:11] Bob Ruffolo: All right, Steph, thanks so much for coming back on, on the show.
[00:36:14] Stephanie: Anytime. Be back soon
[00:36:15] Bob Ruffolo: I'll do that again. All right, Steph, thank you so much for coming back onto the show.
[00:36:19] Stephanie: Anytime. Be back soon
[00:36:21] Bob Ruffolo: All right, this has been another episode of the Endless Customers Podcast. We will see you at the next episode
[00:36:27] Stephanie Baiocchi: If you liked this episode, please take a minute to leave us a review. Thanks for checking out the Endless Customers Podcast.
We had a marketing team meeting at IMPACT a few weeks ago that turned into one of the better debates I've sat through in a while. We were talking about where content goes from here, and specifically whether top-of-funnel articles still earn their place when fewer people click on them.
In almost 17 years of running IMPACT, I've heard CEO after CEO say that if you can't track something, you shouldn't do it. This is a case where that belief could cost you.
To work through it, I sat down with Stephanie Baiocchi, Director of Marketing and Events at IMPACT. Stephanie is a self-described data nerd who runs our marketing like a science experiment, and she came in with numbers on how much of the web is now read by bots instead of people.
Your analytics miss the pages that earned the recommendation
Stephanie pointed out that Cloudflare's data now shows bots making more web page requests than humans, around 57% by their count. For years we filtered bot traffic out of our reports as junk. Some of it still is, but a growing share is AI doing research for someone who's about to buy.
Here's how I see that playing out: A buyer asks ChatGPT for a recommendation, and it visits 10 websites, then 10 more, then 10 more. It does two weeks of research in a few minutes. Then it recommends a company and links to that company's homepage.
That homepage visit shows up in your analytics. The 30 or 40 pages that earned the recommendation never do. As Stephanie said, AI isn't going to ask the human to go back and check the bio page and the team page. It already visited those pages, so the buyer doesn't have to.
What makes AI pick your answer
Everyone in your industry can answer the basic questions. Stephanie's point was that the companies AI cites prove their answer with something underneath it:
- Original data or research
- Real counts of projects completed or customers served
- Customer stories and examples tied to your company name
- Local knowledge, like how flooding in a river valley changes landscaping advice
- An honest take on competitors and on who you're not a good fit for
I brought up Scott Merritt at Honest Fix, an HVAC company that serves about 11 towns.
Scott focuses on creating content that matches the environmental conditions in each of those respective towns. The result is 11 pieces of locally-optimized content that is heavily sourced by AI.
Where AI-written content fits
I pulled up Google during the recording and asked whether it penalizes AI content. The answer on my screen said it does not penalize content simply because AI created it.
So our team asked a harder question: if an informational article is mostly read by AI, is it worth an hour or two of human editing? Stephanie and I agreed it usually isn't, as long as the content is accurate and free of typos.
Service pages are a different story. Those are read by buyers who want to see your people and your work before they reach out, and they deserve a human writer.
Watch the full episode above or listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your podcast platform of choice to hear how Stephanie would make the case for top-of-funnel content to your own leadership team.
Connect with Stephanie
Stephanie Baiocchi is Director of Marketing and Events at IMPACT, where she helps run Endless Customers Live, the company's in-person event held twice a year. She describes herself as a marketer who leans toward the data side, and she approaches content strategy the way a scientist would: form a hypothesis, test it, and adjust. In this episode, she explains why a drop in traffic is the wrong reason to stop publishing top-of-funnel content.
Connect with Luke Wilson on LinkedIn: [LINK NEEDED: Luke's LinkedIn URL]Keep Learning- How to Create Content AI Can't Replicate (and is Worth Citing)
- How AI Makes Recommendations [2026 AI Visibility Report]
- How to Turn Sales Call Transcripts into a Content Engine
- AEO Best Practices: 5 Ways to Improve Your Brand's AI Visibility
__
Endless Customers is a podcast for business owners/leaders, marketers, creatives, and sales teams who want to build trust, attract the right buyers, and drive sustainable revenue growth.
Produced by IMPACT, a sales and marketing training organization, we help companies implement The Endless Customers System by focusing on the right strategies and actions that build trust, educate buyers, and generate more leads.
Interested in sponsorship opportunities or joining us as a guest? Email brand@impactplus.com.
Facing a challenge in your sales and marketing? Schedule a free coaching session with one of our experts and take the step toward business growth.
Posted On:
Oct 13, 2026
Topics:
Share
Subscribe to the Podcast
Get the latest Endless Customers Podcast episodes and practical lessons delivered to your inbox.